Free Shipping On All Orders Above £100
Enjoy a creamy and delicious peanut butter & jelly shake recipe, blending nutty richness with fruity sweetness for the perfect nostalgic treat.
Make the perfect peanut butter & jelly shake with our easy recipe. Discover common mistakes to avoid and fun variation tips designed to satisfy even the fussiest eaters.
Peanut Butter & Jelly Shake
Peanut Butter & Jelly Shake
Course: DessertServings
2
servingsPrep time
10
minutesTotal time
10
minutesWe’ve turned a classic lunchbox favourite into a creamy, playful milkshake that children will love. The nutty richness of peanut butter blends perfectly with the fruity sweetness of jam (or fresh berries if you prefer a lighter version). Dairy-free milk keeps this shake plant-based and wonderfully smooth. Packed with protein from peanuts and natural fruit sugars, it’s a fun way to enjoy a nostalgic flavour in drinkable form.
Ingredients
2 tbsp smooth peanut butter (unsweetened if possible
2 tbsp strawberry or raspberry jam (or ½ cup fresh berries
400ml chilled plant-based milk (oat or almond works well
1 small frozen banana (optional, for extra creaminess
Ice cubes (optional
Whipped dairy-free cream and a drizzle of jam, to serve (optional)
Directions
- Place the peanut butter, jam (or berries), milk, and banana into a blender.
- Blend until smooth and creamy. Add a few ice cubes and blend again if you’d like it chilled and frothy
- Pour into glasses and top with whipped cream and a drizzle of jam for a fun finish.
Key Notes
- Swap the jam for fresh berries if your child prefers less sweetness.
- Try crunchy peanut butter for extra texture.
- Serve with a colourful straw to make it even more appealing for little ones.
- For parents: add a shot of espresso to make it a grown-up PB&J energy shake!
Variation Tips for Fussy Eaters
Swap jelly for fresh fruit – use strawberries, raspberries, or blueberries for natural sweetness.
Try different nut butters – almond or cashew butter offers a milder flavour.
Make it a smoothie – add banana or oats for creaminess and extra nutrition.
Turn it into a dessert shake – top with whipped cream or drizzle with honey.
Go dairy-free – use oat milk, almond milk, or coconut milk for sensitive tummies.
Make mini portions – serve in small cups to avoid overwhelming picky eaters.
Add hidden veggies – a handful of spinach or zucchini blends in without changing taste.
Common Mistakes To Avoid
Using too much peanut butter – makes the shake heavy and overpowering.
Choosing the wrong jelly/jam – overly sweet or artificial Flavours can ruin the balance.
Skipping frozen fruit or ice – leads to a thin, watery texture instead of a creamy shake.
Not blending long enough – leaves lumps of nut butter that fussy eaters may dislike.
Adding too much milk – can dilute the peanut butter and berry flavour.
Using only jelly without fresh fruit – can make it taste flat and overly sugary.
Forgetting to balance sweetness – both peanut butter and jelly are sweet enough; avoid adding unnecessary sugar.
